FINRA Orders Spartan Capital to Pay $3.18 Million in Penalties
FINRA ordered Spartan Capital to pay $2.18 million to customers and a $1 million fine. Former CEO John Lowry was suspended for two years and fined $25,000.
The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) has ordered Spartan Capital Securities LLC to pay customers $2.18 million in restitution and a $1 million fine over recommendations of pre-initial public offering (IPO) investments in funds affiliated with the firm. A settlement also suspends former CEO John Lowry for two years and fines him $25,000.
FINRA found that Spartan failed to conduct reasonable due diligence and fully disclose conflicts of interest, and that offering documents misrepresented material facts. The conduct violated Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI) and anti-fraud provisions of the Securities Act of 1933, FINRA said.
The settlement resolves a pending disciplinary complaint. Lowry, Spartan’s majority owner and the sole owner of the Atlas Funds, was suspended in all capacities. Kim Monchik, the firm’s former acting chief compliance officer and former chief administrative officer, was barred from associating with any FINRA member firm.
Between March and October 2021, Spartan recommended 344 Atlas Fund investments totaling about $24 million to 186 customers, most of them retail investors. The Atlas Funds invested in other pre-IPO funds, called SP Venture Funds, managed by StraightPath Venture Partners LLC. Investors in the Atlas Funds held interests in those funds, not direct shares in private companies.
Lowry created and controlled the Atlas Funds while he owned and controlled Spartan. At his direction, Spartan was the Atlas Funds’ sole placement agent. The funds charged customers markups of 13% to 36% above the prices they paid for interests in the SP Venture Funds. Those charges came on top of disclosed placement and management fees, despite statements to investors that the Atlas Funds would not share in profits from markups on pre-IPO shares.
FINRA found Spartan and Monchik failed to determine whether StraightPath owned or could access shares in the underlying companies. They also did not reasonably examine StraightPath’s operating history, the backgrounds of its principals or the offerings’ pricing, including whether StraightPath marked up interests it sold to the Atlas Funds. FINRA said Spartan therefore lacked a reasonable basis to conclude its recommendations were in retail customers’ best interests, in violation of Reg BI’s Care Obligation.
Spartan, Lowry and Monchik disseminated, or caused the dissemination of, offering documents that misrepresented who charged and benefited from the markups, FINRA found. The documents said a third-party affiliate would sell interests to the Atlas Funds at a markup and that the funds would not share in the profits. The Atlas Funds bought interests directly from StraightPath and charged investors markups that benefited entities owned and controlled by Lowry. The disclosures concealed his additional compensation and the full extent of his financial interest.
FINRA said the conduct violated Rule 2010, which sets standards of commercial honor and principles of trade, by contravening anti-fraud provisions of the Securities Act of 1933. Spartan also violated Reg BI’s Disclosure Obligation by failing to fully and fairly disclose conflicts tied to Lowry’s ownership and financial interests and Monchik’s responsibilities for both Spartan and the Atlas Funds.
Spartan and Monchik also failed to establish written policies and procedures reasonably designed to meet Reg BI’s Care Obligation or to identify, disclose and mitigate conflicts in private placement offerings. FINRA found they failed to reasonably supervise recommendations of the offerings to customers.
In a separate criminal case unrelated to Spartan and its former executives, three former StraightPath principals were sentenced in May to eight to 11 years in federal prison for defrauding investors in StraightPath funds. The fraud included undisclosed markups and selling interests in funds that did not own or have access to shares in the underlying pre-IPO companies.
Spartan, Lowry and Monchik consented to FINRA’s findings without admitting or denying the disciplinary complaint’s allegations.
News is for information only and is not investment advice. Trading forex and CFDs carries a high risk of losing money.