FCA Proposes Pension Performance Fee Exemption for Private Assets
Pension providers would not be required to use the change, which comes with safeguards, and responses to the FCA's consultation are due 14 January 2027.
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has proposed exempting certain performance fees from the charge cap on workplace pension funds. The cap, introduced in 2015, limits charges in workplace default pension funds to 0.75% of funds under management. Providers could opt to use the exemption, subject to protections, but they would not have to add private assets to their portfolios.
The FCA's consultation says the change concerns certain performance fees and is not a general removal of the cap. A fee that sits outside the cap can still reduce investment returns, so providers would need to assess the full economic outcome, including the exempted charge. Compliance with the remaining cap would not be enough on its own to show value. The investment case should hold up after costs, and it should account for how uncertain and how timely the returns are.
Therese Chambers, the FCA's Executive Director of Enforcement and Market Integrity, said greater flexibility is "not a licence to charge more." Any higher charges, she said, must be justified by additional value, and firms must weigh returns, risks and costs when deciding what is in savers' best interests. Governance around an investment therefore matters at least as much as the permission to consider it.
Valuations and performance fees
Private assets are not priced continuously through active public trading, so a reported gain may rest on an estimate before any sale is completed. Where a manager's pay is tied to performance, the assumptions behind that estimate can affect both the pension fund's reported results and the manager's compensation. Valuation scrutiny is therefore part of fee control.
The FCA's earlier review of private-market valuation practices found areas for improvement on conflicts, independence and valuations during market disruption. Those findings help explain why the consultation pairs flexibility with safeguards. Providers would need enough information to challenge how performance is measured, particularly if market conditions change or an asset cannot be sold near its recorded value.
The proposed protections also cover transparency and how fees are shared between savers. That matters for people who join, leave or change contributions at different points in an investment's life. An arrangement can look reasonable at fund level while charging members unevenly. Providers and Independent Governance Committees would need enough detail to see those outcomes and to work out who pays when performance fees become payable.
Trust-based schemes and market access
Trust-based schemes have kept certain performance fees outside the charge cap since 2023, and the proposals would move the FCA regime closer to that treatment. Greater consistency could simplify choices for providers that run both structures. It could also reduce how far a pension's legal form determines which fee arrangements it can accommodate.
The moves sit alongside a wider push to improve access to private markets. The PISCES (Private Intermittent Securities and Capital Exchange System) framework covers intermittent trading in private shares and addresses secondary transactions. The London Stock Exchange's digital infrastructure for private funds addresses another part of access. Neither removes the need for a pension provider to assess liquidity, valuation and suitability at portfolio level.
Private investments can have long holding periods, which may suit part of a pension portfolio. A long holding period does not give schemes unlimited room to hold illiquid assets. Schemes still face transfers, benefit payments and changes in membership, so the question is how an allocation fits the fund's cash needs and risk profile, including in conditions where selling an asset becomes unusually hard.
Evidence for more choice
The World Federation of Exchanges has raised concerns about private-market transparency, a worry that sits within a wider policy debate over expanding access. Pension providers will need to explain why the exposure improves the portfolio compared with alternatives that carry different fee terms.
The FCA's earlier scrutiny of how investment platforms treated cash interest involved a different product and charging method. It still focused on the economics that reached the customer. For pensions, the comparison that matters is what savers retain after all relevant costs.
Until the final rules are settled, the proposal should not be treated as an exemption already available under the new framework. Responses to the consultation are due by 14 January 2027, and the FCA expects final rules in summer 2027 after considering feedback.
News is for information only and is not investment advice. Trading forex and CFDs carries a high risk of losing money.